11 Best Hotels in Sister Bay, WI

Written by Anietra Hamper
Jul 30, 2019

The village of Sister Bay in Door County Wisconsin is only three square miles but it is one of the top vacation spots on the peninsula, with plenty of lodging to accommodate the visitors who come to enjoy the quiet waterside community. All the hotels, bed and breakfasts, resorts, and locally owned inns reflect an old-school cottage, community charm to help you unwind, but they also have modern conveniences to keep you connected when you need it.

Staying in Sister Bay keeps you close to the Peninsula State Park and Newport State Park. It is also where you catch the ferries to Washington Island.

If you are looking for a romantic getaway, you can enjoy a waterfront room to watch a sunrise over Green Bay from your private patio. Families will appreciate the family room accommodations that offer kitchenettes and bunk beds for convenience. Many of the hotels and lodges are open year-round, so you can find a favorite place to make returning to Door County an annual tradition.

1. Country House Resort

Photo Source: Country House Resort

The adults-only Country House Resort is a peaceful place to stay for a romantic weekend or private retreat for a special occasion. The resort sits on 27 acres in the woods in Sister Bay, with some of the best views of the water.

The rooms have private balconies, so you can enjoy the waterfront location with a cup of coffee in the morning. Rooms come with refrigerators and microwaves. Some rooms are available with whirlpool baths and gas fireplaces. The property has an outdoor pool and whirlpool, gardens, nature trails, and a dock available for guests to use.

Since the Country House Resort is in the heart of recreational areas, you can borrow bikes, kayaks, and tennis equipment to use during your stay. There are several dog-friendly rooms at the resort that come with a dog basket upon check-in, an in-room food and water bowl, an outside dog wash area, and a dog bed upon request. Guests receive complimentary breakfast.

Address: 2468 Sunnyside Road, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Country House Resort

2. Open Hearth Lodge

Photo Source: Open Hearth Lodge

The quiet Open Hearth Lodge sits on 6.5-acres in a meadow in Sister Bay just across the village border. While the lodge has plenty of acreage to enjoy for walks and easy access to snowmobile trails in the winter, it is close to many additional biking and hiking trails in Sister Bay.

There are several communal areas at the lodge for guests to use throughout their stay like the stone fireplace lounge, a breakfast lounge, computer area with games available, and an outdoor patio with a grill.

Rooms range from lodge rooms with just the basics to suites with a refrigerator, microwave, sitting areas, and whirlpool tubs. Guests can use the indoor swimming pool, whirlpool, sauna, and fitness center. Guests also receive free Wi-Fi, a daily complimentary continental breakfast, and coffee is available throughout the day. Open Hearth Lodge is open year-round.

Address: 2669 S. Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Open Hearth Lodge

3. Coachlite Inn of Sister Bay

Photo Source: Coachlite Inn of Sister Bay

For guests who like a little bit of seclusion, the Coachlite Inn of Sister Bay is tucked away from the downtown scene but it is still within walking distance of the shops and restaurants. The Coachlite Inn location is adjacent to walking, biking, and snowmobile trails, so it is an ideal lodging option for guests who plan to spend a lot of time outdoors. The Inn is less than a mile from galleries, golf courses, theaters, and the Washington Island ferry.

All of the rooms and suites have microwaves, refrigerators, and coffee makers. Some suites also have fireplaces and double whirlpool tubs or kitchenettes.

Two suites offer exceptional extras for special getaways: The Private Pond Suite has a king bed and sofa bed plus a full kitchen and spacious living and dining areas. The suite has a whirlpool, private parking, fire ring, grill, and secluded yard. The Chalet Suite accommodates up to 14 people in three bedrooms. There is a full kitchen, living room, dining room, and outdoor patio. Guests receive free breakfast and can enjoy it on the outdoor patio. The inn is open year-round.

Address: 2544 S. Bay Shore Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Coachlite Inn of Sister Bay

4. Pheasant Park

Photo Source: Pheasant Park

The Pheasant Park resort is an elegant country-style retreat that is close to the largest public waterfront in Door County. It is located close to two state parks, Sister Bay boutiques, local restaurants, golf courses, cross country skiing, and tennis courts. Pheasant Park is close to many outdoor activities, including golf courses, paddleboat rentals, state parks, and fishing.

The resort has two- and three-bedroom suites that include a whirlpool tub and a full kitchen. There are plenty of activities to do on-site if you do not feel like leaving the property. There is an indoor and outdoor pool, a whirlpool and sauna, and a fitness center. For kids, there is a children's play area and an arcade to keep them busy. Guests can use the disc golf course and propane grills on the property. Pheasant Park is open year-round.

Address: 2236 Mill Road, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Pheasant Park

5. The Inn at Little Sister Hill

Photo Source: The Inn at Little Sister Hill

If you want the best of both Sister Bay and the village of Ephraim then The Inn at Little Sister Hill is a great location for your vacation, as it sits between both towns. The Inn is close to all of Sister Bay's charm including the small shops, musical entertainment, and nearby outdoor activities. The Inn at Little Sister Hill is open seasonally from Memorial Day to Labor Day.

There are several types of suites available, from one and two bedrooms to options that have a loft, private patio, and private balcony. All of the suites come with full kitchens, a living room, and dining area.

The property has a heated outdoor pool and gas grills that guests can use, as well as free Wi-Fi and laundry facilities available. There is a picnic area and fire pit on the grounds, and guests are welcome to borrow complimentary bicycles to explore Sister Bay on two wheels.

Address: 2715 Little Sister Hill Road, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: The Inn at Little Sister Hill

6. Nordic Lodge

Photo Source: Nordic Lodge

The wooded serenity of the Nordic Lodge is nice because you can enjoy both the water and the lush forest setting at once. The lodge is located in downtown Sister Bay, so guests have easy access to the shops and restaurants. It is also only two miles from the village of Ephraim and the famous 1906 Wilson's Ice Cream Parlor that is a Door County must-try.

All of the Nordic Lodge rooms have a microwave, refrigerator, coffee maker, and private deck. There are suite rooms available that include a living room, separate bedroom, and a full kitchen and dining area. Guests get free Wi-Fi and a complimentary continental breakfast. There is an indoor pool, whirlpool, and comfortable outdoor deck for the days that you want to relax at the lodge. The Nordic Lodge is a pet-friendly hotel.

Address: 2721 Nordic Drive, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Nordic Lodge

7. Scandinavian Lodge

Photo Source: Scandinavian Lodge

The Scandinavian Lodge is a condominium hotel located in Sister Bay and close to all of the boutiques and small restaurants. There are a range of room options with nice amenities, especially if you plan to stay for a week or more. The Scandinavian Lodge has bikes that guests can rent to use around the village or spend the day riding on one of the local bike trails.

All of the condominium suites have full kitchens, a living room, dining area, whirlpool, and gas fireplace. There are even designated one-bedroom condos that are great for romantic getaways because they only accommodate two people and have Jacuzzi tubs and a cozy fireplace. Larger condominiums for families or couples traveling together come with two or three bedrooms.

The resort has an indoor and outdoor pool, whirlpool, and a children's pool. Guests can use the fitness center, tennis courts, and game room. The lodge is open year-round.

Address: 264 Highway 57, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Scandinavian Lodge

8. Sister Bay Inn

Photo Source: Sister Bay Inn

The Sister Bay Inn is on the budget-friendly side of lodging in Sister Bay but it is a nice place if you are not looking to spend money on extra amenities. The hotel is just off the main route through the village so there is some privacy, but as with everything in Sister Bay, you are only a few streets away from the main action downtown.

The Sister Bay Inn rooms have the basics, with one or two beds, free WiFi, refrigerators, coffee makers, and televisions. Guests have access to the heated outdoor swimming pool and whirlpool. Some of the rooms come with private patios and balconies. There is green space at the inn with a grill, so you can enjoy a cookout before relaxing for the evening sunset. Guests can also play a game of horseshoes on the lawn. The inn has some pet-friendly rooms and is open year-round.

Address: 10490 State Highway 57, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Sister Bay Inn

9. Goose & Twigs

Sister Bay waterfront near Goose & Twigs| Richie Diesterheft / photo modified

If you select lodging based on environmentally friendly practices then Goose and Twigs is tops for a green getaway in Sister Bay. It is close to all of the Sister Bay attractions and parks, so you can walk to almost everything. It is only a three-minute walk to the water and the Waterfront Park or Sister Bay Beach.

Rooms have basic amenities, and suites come with extras like a kitchenette, living room, and free Wi-Fi. King and Queen rooms are available with one or two beds or a bed and sofa bed. Guests receive complimentary breakfast and there is a coffee shop on-site. Since the hotel is environmentally friendly there is an electric car charger available and an electric/hybrid car discount for guests who drive them.

Address: 2333 Mill Road, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Goose & Twigs

10. The Eagle Harbor Inn

Photo Source: The Eagle Harbor Inn

If you cannot find lodging in the heart of Sister Bay, there are some nice hotels in the neighboring village of Ephraim, which is less than four miles away. The Eagle Harbor Inn is only 3.5 miles away from Sister Bay in Ephraim's Historic District. It is secluded on five acres of private property.

There are lodge rooms and separate cottages with whirlpool suites if you are looking for added privacy or a celebrating a special getaway. All the rooms and suites in Eagle Harbor Inn are uniquely decorated with antique furniture and have sitting areas and private bathrooms.

Breakfast is included, with a menu of locally sourced food or, if you prefer to sleep in, you can upgrade to have a Breakfast Basket for two delivered to your room.

The inn has indoor and outdoor pools, a fitness center, and free Wi-Fi. Main lodge guests get complimentary breakfast, and all of the guests are welcome to enjoy the afternoon treats that are made fresh daily.

The Eagle Harbor Inn is located close to the waterfront of Eagle Harbor and Peninsula State Park.

Address: 9914 Water Street, Ephraim, Wisconsin

Accommodation: The Eagle Harbor Inn

11. Bay Breeze Resort

Photo Source: Bay Breeze Resort

The Bay Breeze Resort is also located in Ephraim, less than four miles away from Sister Bay. The resort has luxury suites on the waterfront with some of the best views of Eagle Harbor. It is only a short drive to Sister Bay, and staying in Ephraim will enable you to also explore this historic district, which has a number of original cottages in the area. The Bay Breeze Resort is 3.5 miles from Peninsula State Park, where you can catch a performance by the Northern Sky Theater.

The Bay Breeze Resort guest rooms have microwaves, refrigerators, and free Wi-Fi, and they offer views of the gardens or the bay. All the rooms have different amenities that you can select from, like whirlpool tubs, Kohler rain showers, and gas fireplaces. The resort has a private beach that guests can use. The resort also has a heated outdoor pool and whirlpool.

Address: 9844 Water Street, Ephraim, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Bay Breeze Resort

More Related Articles on PlanetWare.com

Door County: Exploring Door County is a fun and easy vacation no matter where you choose to stay. Whether you are looking for a romantic getaway or exploring the great outdoors on the peninsula, there is a village and an experience to fill your time. In fact, there are 19 villages in Door County, a few that are among the best small towns in Wisconsin. Explore Peninsula State Park or one of several state parks along the 70-mile stretch of peninsula. Take a kayaking trip along stretches of the 300 miles of coastline that take you into the waters of Green Bay or Lake Michigan.

Day Trips from Door County: Door County is a great place to set up a home base if you want to vacation in the peninsula and plan day trips to some of Wisconsin's other great cities. Some of the best day trips from Door County include Milwaukee, which is less than three hours from Sturgeon Bay, and Green Bay, which has several historical sites, museums, and Lambeau Field.

Discover destinations, find outdoor adventures, follow the journeys of our travel writers around the world, and be inspired.

More on Wisconsin