Ohio's Amish Country: 12 Highlights and Hidden Treasures

The Amish communities that exist throughout Ohio provide the kind of meandering back roads that make for relaxing getaways and day trips. Go for a long drive to soak in a more simple way of life as you watch the Amish workers in the fields and see laundry drying on the line. Tucked away in these small communities are hidden gems of family-owned stores and experiences that are worth a stop, if you can find them.

The five-county region in northeast Ohio that includes Holmes, Adams, Geauga, Wayne, and Tuscarawas counties is considered Ohio's Amish country, with working farms and rolling landscapes. You will not find advertisements for things to do and tourist attractions in Amish country because what exists there supports their quiet way of life. As you drive through these counties, prepare to slow down a bit for the Amish buggies and enjoy a few stops that you are guaranteed to remember - the kind of places that typically only the locals know.

1 Amish Country Byways

Amish Country Byways
Amish Country Byways

The Amish Country Byway is 160 miles of designated roadways that take you through the most scenic routes of Ohio's Amish country in Holmes County. One of the most prized things to do in Amish country is drive through the rolling hills and enjoy the simple life that you see out the window. As one of Ohio's Scenic Byways, you will drive past quaint homes and B&Bs and quiet country living. Stop for a homemade meal at one of the many local restaurants that you pass along the way or pick up fresh meat and produce from a roadside stand.

If you have time to spare, plan two to three days to enjoy the byway experience and just see where the road takes you. You can plot your stops for the night or play it by ear. Keep in mind that once night falls in Amish country, there are few lights for navigation, so you are best to make your evening meal and lodging arrangements during the daylight hours. Maps of the byway are available from the Ohio Department of Transportation or the Holmes County Chamber of Commerce.

2 Yoder's Bargain Store

Yoder's Bargain Store
Yoder's Bargain Store | Photo Copyright: Anietra Hamper

Yoder's Bargain Store in Fredericksburg is one of the great finds in Ohio's Amish country, partly because it is truly a hidden gem. Marked only by a small rock along the berm of the road, the store is where the Amish come to buy their goods as indicated by the number of horse and buggies that you will see tied up outside.

The bargain store is on the property of an Amish family, and while it is open to the public, you might feel a bit intrusive pulling up the mile-long private driveway. Rest assured, it is okay. Once inside the barn, it is a shopper's paradise. You will find glassware, cookware, homeopathic ointment, wool hats, children's clothes, purses, work gloves, candy, religious figurines, and trinkets that cost only pennies on the dollar compared to a traditional store.

Part of the thrill of visiting Yoder's Bargain Store is the discovery of items you did not know you needed. There are several floors for perusing and aisles of shelves with miss-match items that are all for sale. The only light in the store is from small windows to the outside. If you visit, take cash. This is an Amish store, so they do not take credit cards and do not even have a register.

Address: 7802 Salt Creek Road, Fredericksburg, Ohio

3 Raber's Shoe and Saddlery

Leather saddle
Leather saddle

You might feel like you are driving to the middle of nowhere in your search for Raber's Shoe and Saddlery, but you can be sure you will get some of the best leather products here you have ever purchased. Deep in the heart of Adams County, this is a find. Owned and operated by an Amish family, Raber's is known for their high quality, custom-made products.

You will find leather work boots, shoes, and other leather goods. Since the store caters to the Amish, you can also find custom-made horse saddles and shoe repair services. You may even find yourself making a trip back every few years just for new boots.

Address: 5212 Unity Road, Peebles, Ohio

4 Walnut Creek Cheese

Walnut Creek Cheese
Walnut Creek Cheese

Walnut Creek Cheese is an experience worth the drive. The store is full of fresh homemade baked goods and food and is a paradise for cooks. You can buy cooking ingredients in bulk, which makes it a great place to stock up on items that can be expensive at grocery stores. Since it is located in the heart of Amish country, where homemade food is some of the best, this is where to find the freshest ingredients at great prices.

You can stock up on locally made cheese and a wide selection (more than 75 varieties) of fresh jams and jellies that are made in Holmes County. The bakery in the store will no doubt tempt your senses with the bread and pies that are still warm when they are put onto the shelves.

The gift shop has plenty of kitchenware items that you may have never seen before. Amish cookbooks are available with some of the best recipes you will find anywhere for comfort food.

Address: 2641 OH-39, Walnut Creek, Ohio

5 End of the Commons General Store

End of the Commons General Store
End of the Commons General Store | Photo Copyright: Anietra Hamper

If you are looking for a dose of nostalgia that will take you back to your childhood, then the End of the Commons General Store is worth a visit. Located in Mesopotamia, it is the oldest General Store in Ohio. Just inside the door are bins of bundled penny candy that still costs only a penny. As you walk from one room to the next, there is no shortage of old time toys and trinkets for sale, like x-ray goggles and bike streamers. The store sells hard-to-find baking ingredients, cooking utensils, and cookie cutters.

The large glass cooler in the front of the store is like an old-school time machine. It is filled with glass bottle soda pop and more than 150 selections, like Route 66 Cream Soda and Capt'n Eli's Orange Pop. You will even find unique apothecary items at the store and soaps from another era, like Grandma's Lye soap.

Throughout the store, antiques and memorabilia decorate the walls and ceiling. It is a fun trip back in time that will keep you there longer than you think you will stay.

Address: 4366 Kinsman Road, Mesopotamia, Ohio

6 The Victorian House Museum

The Victorian House Museum in Millersburg, in Holmes County, is full of history about Ohio's largest Amish settlement. The elegant 28-room Victorian home is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and has been featured on a number of television shows. The museum will take you back to the early 1900s as you walk through the history of the area, with glassware, furniture, and period pieces on display.

One of the best times to visit the Victorian House Museum is during the winter, when the museum home is decorated with holiday décor and more than 40 trees. Theatrical effects with lights and sound are added to usher you back to the Victorian era. A tour through the home will give you perspective on the Ohio's Amish roots.

Address: 484 Wooster Road, Millersburg, Ohio

7 Sweetwater Farm

Fresh produce and berries
Fresh produce and berries

The Sweetwater Farm in Sugarcreek is a hidden gem that anyone with a green thumb or a taste for organic produce will enjoy. The small family-run business is only open from May through November. You will find a range of fresh fruits and vegetables that were raised on the farm. It is some of the freshest produce you can find for a reasonable price. They also specialize in berries, like blueberries and strawberries, that are used in many local jams.

The farm is a favorite of locals who go for the plush hanging baskets, bedding plants, and quality mulch. Only an unassuming stand by the road and small sign mark the family farm, but the products are some of the best you will find in the region.

Address: 217 Buckeye Street, Sugarcreek, Ohio

8 The Depot

The Depot at the Middlefield Historical Society is a 1930s ice cream parlor complete with the stools and the heaping scoops of your favorite flavor. A stop at the Depot is a refreshing way to break up your visit to Amish country, and it's a place where you can order old-fashioned sodas and sundaes while taking in some of the local history. The shop is in an old B&O Railroad depot that was built in 1874. It was destroyed by fire and re-built in 1910 and eventually turned into an ice cream parlor.

The Depot features historical memorabilia, and the building has a covered front porch where you can take a few minutes to relax. Be sure to check out the caboose car next to the depot.

Address: 14979 S. State Avenue, Middlefield, Ohio

9 Sweet Briar Suri Alpaca Farm

Brown alpaca
Brown alpaca

Whether you are actively looking for an alpaca or just open for something fun to do on your visit to Amish country, you might enjoy the Sweet Briar Suri Alpaca Farm in Burton, Ohio. The alpaca farm is fun to visit for a lesson on an animal you may not know much about. You can also purchase end products like sweaters. One of the most enjoyable things to do at the farm is watch a live alpaca auction. Auctions take place throughout the year for specialty-bred alpacas, and if the mood strikes, you can even bid on one.

Address: 12375 Pond Road, Burton, Ohio

10 Amish Cheese Tours

Amish Cheese Tours

One of the best and most delicious things to do in Amish country is visit a cheese factory and take a cheesemaking tour. You will see several cheese factories as you drive, and most offer daily tours. Heini's Cheese Chalet in Berlin, Guggisberg Cheese in Sugarcreek, and Steiner Dairy in Baltic offer quality products and tours. You can go behind-the-scenes to see the process of how local cheese is made using local products and labor.

Cheese tours always end with samples of the product. You will find specialty cheeses in these stores that you will not find elsewhere. You can also stock up on favorite varieties for a great price, which will be substantially lower at factory stores than in your local grocery. Be sure to look for snack bags that offer cheese crumbles, which are factory leftovers that are bagged for quick sale, but they make great snacks.

11 Baltic Country Meats & Deli

Cheese plate
Cheese plate

Some of the freshest meats you can buy are straight from the farm at Baltic Meats & Deli in Baltic, Ohio. All meat curing and smoking is done in-house, and all meats are locally raised. If you are looking for fresh meat and cheese to take home, this is a good stop since all meats are cut fresh daily, and the cheese is locally made. Your best bet is to bring a cooler and stock up.

Address: 3457 State Route 93, Baltic, Ohio

12 Amish Country Riding Stables

Amish Country Riding Stables
Amish Country Riding Stables | Photo Copyright: Anietra Hamper

If you prefer to enjoy a more active visit to Amish country, you can take a horseback ride through some of Ohio's beautiful countryside with Amish Country Riding Stables. The guided horseback trips are offered with small groups of only two to five riders at a time. This is one of the best ways to enjoy the area for both experienced and inexperienced riders.

Rides typically last around 45 minutes, so you can include this along with several other stops in one day. If you do not want to ride, you can just stop to enjoy the elegant horses on the property. In the winter, horse-drawn carriage rides are a huge draw in this pristine landscape. They are arranged through the Guggisberg Swiss Inn and Amish Country Riding Stables. Rides fill up quickly and depend on the weather, so it is best to look into reservations early to reserve a spot.

Address: 5025 SR 557, Millersburg, Ohio

Discover destinations, find outdoor adventures, follow the journeys of our travel writers around the world, and be inspired.

More on Ohio