16 Top-Rated Resorts in Door County, WI

Written by Anietra Hamper
Jul 30, 2019

While quaint cottages, inns, and bed and breakfasts are among the most popular vacation lodging options in Door County, Wisconsin, there are a number of resorts throughout the peninsula that offer memorable vacation getaways. The resorts in Door County have the essence of casual elegance to complement the cottage-style villages that make up the character of the 70-mile-long peninsula bordered by the waters of Green Bay and Lake Michigan.

You can find family resorts and some with private beaches on the waterfront. There are adults-only resorts, and some that sit on the famous limestone bluffs in the region.

The communities of Sturgeon Bay, Egg Harbor, Sister Bay, Ephraim, Fish Creek, and others each have their own kind of charm. While a resort offers on-site amenities that enable you to stay close to home on vacation, the nice element about staying in Door County is that no matter where you rest your head at night, you can easily travel between the towns during your stay. Most are only a few minutes apart. Here is a list of some of the best Door County resorts to get you started on your vacation search.

1. Landmark Resort

Photo Source: Landmark Resort

The Landmark Resort in Egg Harbor is the biggest resort in Door County. One of its main features is its spectacular view of the water. It is located on a huge bluff overlooking Green Bay. The resort has two- and three-bedroom suites with all the comforts of home, including full kitchens, dining rooms, living rooms, and a deck to relax and enjoy the scenery.

The 40-acre property has a 24-hour indoor swimming pool, outdoor pools, whirlpools, steam rooms, fitness center, three tennis courts, game room, on-site laundry, hiking trails on the property, free Wi-Fi, and casual dining on-site. You are only a short drive from the local art galleries and the Egg Harbor marina.

Address: 4929 Landmark Drive, Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Landmark Resort

2. Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort

Photo Source: Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort

If you want to stay close to Sturgeon Bay, the Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort is an all-suite resort with scenic views from every balcony. Each of the 38 suites has separate sleeping, living, and dining space. All come with full kitchens for when you choose to dine-in, whirlpool tubs, covered balconies for comfortable sunset views of the bay, and gas fireplaces.

The property has indoor and outdoor pools, picnic areas on the shoreline, free paddleboat rental, and free Wi-Fi. This location is close to all the modern shopping and restaurants in Sturgeon Bay and it can serve as a nice location from which to make day trips to other parts of Door County.

Address: 4303 Bay Shore Drive, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort

3. Homestead Suites

Photo Source: Homestead Suites

Fish Creek has long been one of the most popular vacation spots in Door County, and Homestead Suites is a nice, independently owned resort that caters to the cottage-feel lodging but with all of the modern amenities and conveniences. There are several options of home rentals, condos, suites, and rooms. The five-bedroom Homestead Park House is a rental home that sleeps up to 14 people and has a full kitchen and living area plus a fireplace and patio.

The townhouse condo and several other guesthouses are ideal for four or six guests and have luxury suites. Suites come with options like a gas fireplace, whirlpool tub, refrigerator and microwave, and walk-in rain showers. The property has indoor and outdoor pools, a whirlpool and sauna, and a fitness center. Guests receive free continental breakfast.

Address: 4006 Main Street, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Homestead Suites

4. White Gull Inn

Photo Source: White Gull Inn

An elegant resort in Fish Creek that also has one of the best traditional Door County Wisconsin fish boils is the White Gull Inn. While it is considered a bed and breakfast, the White Gull Inn is a restored 1896 property in the heart of Fish Creek, meaning you do not have to go far to enjoy the full charm of Door County, with boutiques and quaint cafés that are right outside your front door.

There are 17 uniquely decorated suites and cottages, most with fireplaces and whirlpool baths. Complimentary coffee is delivered to your room each morning. Guests receive a complimentary full breakfast. You might want to try their famous cherry-stuffed French Toast using cherries grown right in the region.

Address: 4225 Main Street, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: White Gull Inn

5. The Eagle Harbor Inn

Photo Source: The Eagle Harbor Inn

The Eagle Harbor Inn is located in Ephraim's Historic District on five acres of private property. It is a cross between a quaint bed and breakfast and a luxury resort.

Whirlpool suites are located in separate cottages on the property for those looking for privacy or a special getaway. Rooms and suites located in the inn are uniquely decorated, with antique furniture, a sitting area, and private bathrooms. Breakfast is included, with a menu of locally sourced food, or you can upgrade to have breakfast in bed with a Breakfast Basket for two delivered to your room.

During your stay at the Eagle Harbor Inn, you can enjoy the indoor and outdoor pools, a fitness center, and free Wi-Fi. Guests also get complimentary breakfast. Kick back in one of the beach chairs on the property and enjoy an afternoon sweet made fresh daily. You are close to the waterfront to take a morning stroll and the Peninsula State Park, where you can hike for the day or take in an evening performance of the Northern Sky Theater.

Address: 9914 Water Street, Ephraim, Wisconsin

Accommodation: The Eagle Harbor Inn

6. Edgewater Resort

Photo Source: Edgewater Resort

The Edgewater Resort is a historic waterfront resort in Ephraim that has a nostalgic charm. Open the windows to feel the morning breeze coming in off Eagle Harbor. Guests can choose from waterfront suites or private cottages. Suites have whirlpool baths, kitchens, and fireplaces. The one- and two-bedroom cottages come with home amenities and some are pet friendly. There is also a honeymoon studio suite and courtyard rooms available.

The resort has a pool and fitness center available for guests. Besides the perfect waterfront view, Edgewater Resort is located in the center of Ephraim, so you are close to village shops and great dining at the Old Post Office Restaurant next door, which has homemade food and one of the best traditional Door County fish boils.

Address: 10040 Water Street, Highway 42, Ephraim, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Edgewater Resort

7. Country House Resort

Photo Source: Country House Resort

The Country House Resort sits on a bluff in Sister Bay making for stunning views during your stay. This is an adults-only resort, located on the waterfront, with rooms that have private balconies. Rooms come with microwaves and refrigerators, and some come with whirlpool baths and gas fireplaces. Guests receive complimentary breakfast. The property has an outdoor pool and whirlpool, nature trails, a fishing dock, and gardens.

You can borrow bikes, kayaks, and tennis equipment from the resort to use. There are a number of pet-friendly rooms at the resort that come with amenities, including a dog basket upon check-in and outside dog wash area, in-room food and water bowls, and a dog bed upon request.

Address: 2468 Sunnyside Road, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Country House Resort

8. Scandinavian Lodge

Scandinavian Lodge

The Scandinavian Lodge is a condominium hotel that has a range of room options. It is located near Sister Bay and is close to shopping and dining options. If you are looking for a romantic getaway, the lodge has one-bedroom condos with Jacuzzi tubs and fireplaces or a special "designed-for-two" studio suite.

For guests that require more space or for families there are two- and three-bedroom condos available. The resort has an indoor and outdoor pool, whirlpool, and a children's pool. Guests can use the fitness center, tennis courts, and game room. For a fun way to check out Sister Bay, you can rent bikes from the lodge.

Address: 264 Highway 57, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Scandinavian Lodge

9. Gordon Lodge

Photo Source: Gordon Lodge

For a nice waterfront view during your stay in Door County, the Gordon Lodge resort in Baileys Harbor is ideal. The lodge is a waterfront resort on the Lake Michigan side of the peninsula, with a private beach for guests to use. Lodging options include rooms and suites, water-view cottages, and a five-bedroom guesthouse. Rooms have mini-refrigerators, microwaves, and coffee makers. Guests receive a complimentary breakfast buffet.

Guests also have access to the private beach, and free rentals of bicycles and kayaks to use during their stay.

Address: 1420 Pine Drive, Baileys Harbor, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Gordon Lodge

10. Pheasant Park

Photo Source: Pheasant Park

The Pheasant Park resort in Sister Bay is an elegant country retreat located close to the largest public waterfront in Door County. The resort has two- and three-bedroom suites with whirlpool tubs and a full kitchen. The resort is close to all of the Sister Bay activities and shops but there is plenty to do right on the property.

There is an indoor and outdoor pool, whirlpool, and sauna, as well as a fitness center and arcade. The property has a children's play area, disc golf, and propane grills for guests to use. Pheasant Park is close to many outdoor activities, including golf courses, paddleboat rentals, state parks, and fishing.

Address: 2236 Mill Road, Sister Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Pheasant Park

11. Shallows Resort

Photo Source: Shallows Resort

The Shallows Resort in Egg Harbor is a quiet Door County retreat set between woodlands and a private shoreline on Green Bay. The resort has several lodging options from shoreline rooms, townhouses, cottages, and rental homes each with all of the amenities that you will need for a getaway. All guests have access to the private waterfront, pool, and hot tub, picnic areas, and a private dock.

Guests can also borrow kayaks, bicycles, and canoes to enjoy the waterfront outside their front door. Be sure to take advantage of one of the bonfire pits located on the beach for a perfect Door County evening. The lodge can supply firewood.

Address: 7353 Horseshoe Bay Road, Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Shallows Resort

12. Bay Shore Inn

Photo Source: Bay Shore Inn

The Bay Shore Inn condo resort in Sturgeon Bay is a comfortable cottage getaway with one-, two-, and three-bedroom suites available. All suites have private decks, a full kitchen, living room, and dining area. There is a private beach on the property for guests to use and free use of kayaks.

Guests have access to complimentary bikes or use of the fitness center, tennis courts, and game room. There are indoor and outdoor pools available and a massage therapist on-site for days when you need extra pampering. The resort is nice for families due to the many rentals available and on-site amenities like a children's playground and campfire pit.

Address: 4205 Bay Shore Drive, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Bay Shore Inn

13. Meadow Ridge Resort

Photo Source: Meadow Ridge Resort

A nice resort in Egg Harbor is the Meadow Ridge Resort with luxury two- and three-bedroom condominiums available. The condos each have a full kitchen, patio, and whirlpool baths. You are located near the shops and galleries along the main stretch in Egg Harbor.

On the resort property, you can take advantage of walking the nature trails and or use the fitness center. The resort has an indoor/outdoor pool and large aquatic center with slides and water features, which is great for families. The resort is close to the Alpine Country Club for golf and the Egg Harbor Beach.

Address: 7573 State Highway 42, Egg Harbor, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Meadow Ridge Resort

14. Bay Breeze Resort

Photo Source: Bay Breeze Resort

The Bay Breeze Resort in Ephraim has luxury suites and sits right on the waterfront of Eagle Harbor. The guest rooms have a variety of amenities, from whirlpool tubs and Kohler rain showers to gas fireplaces. Rooms also have microwaves and refrigerators and come with garden views or water views. The resort has a private beach and is close to outdoor activities like hiking at Peninsula State Park. The resort also has a heated outdoor pool and whirlpool.

Address: 9844 Water Street, Ephraim, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Bay Breeze Resort

15. The Lodge at Leathem Smith

Photo Source: The Lodge at Leathem Smith

For a luxury resort getaway in Sturgeon Bay, the Lodge at Leathem Smith can complete the experience with extras like live music at the lodge, a marina for boaters, and an evening fish fry. The guest rooms and suites at the lodge have kitchenettes, whirlpool baths, and patios. Some of the rooms come with a dining area, utensils, gas fireplace, and whirlpool tub. Guests receive a complimentary breakfast.

There is a pool on-site, but you might choose to enjoy the shores of nearby Lake Michigan or walk around in downtown Sturgeon Bay, which is close to the resort.

Address: 1640 Memorial Drive, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: The Lodge at Leathem Smith

16. AppleCreek Resort Hotel & Suites

Photo Source: AppleCreek Resort Hotel & Suites

The AppleCreek Resort in Fish Creek is in a convenient location. AppleCreek Resort is close to the public beach, Peninsula State Park, and many sightseeing opportunities like the Door County Trolley Tours. Guest rooms have refrigerators and easy access to the pool and sun deck. Some suites have a fireplace, whirlpool tub, and an upper or lower balcony.

A guesthouse is available for those who need more space and comes with two bedrooms, a fireplace, and a full kitchen. The resort has an indoor pool and hot tub for guests to use.

Address: 3941 WI Hwy 42, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: AppleCreek Resort Hotel & Suites

More Related Articles on PlanetWare.com

Door County: The peninsula of Door County has more than 300 miles of coastline to explore and more than 19 small communities to visit to enjoy the outdoors, with activities like kayaking, galleries, and orchards. The region has many resorts, cottages, B&Bs, and hotels, so you can stay in an area like Fish Creek or Sister Bay in the kind of lodging that fits your vacation.

Day Trips from Door County: While there is so much to explore on the peninsula, you can make a base in Door County in an area like Sturgeon Bay and take day trips to other cities. Catch a Packers game in Green Bay, which is less than an hour away, and experience the fanfare on Lambeau Field. You can take a 2.5-hour drive to Milwaukee from Sturgeon Bay and enjoy the museums and lakefront.

Discover destinations, find outdoor adventures, follow the journeys of our travel writers around the world, and be inspired.

More on Wisconsin