×

15 Best Hotels in Sturgeon Bay, WI

Written by Anietra Hamper
Jul 30, 2019

The town of Sturgeon Bay is considered the entry point to Door County, Wisconsin, so there are more hotel options available than in the other villages along the peninsula. It is the biggest town in Door County and has the best selection of hotels, ranging from commercial chain hotels to independently owned hotels, bed and breakfasts, and small resorts that are typical in the region.

Many of the Sturgeon Bay lodging choices have suites that are great for families, and amenities like bike rentals or campfire pits that add a little something extra to your vacation. Whether you are looking for boutique and unique inns or a chain hotel with standard amenities, you have the broadest options in Sturgeon Bay.

1. Bay Shore Inn

Photo Source: Bay Shore Inn

The Bay Shore Inn is a nice condominium resort in Sturgeon Bay that feels like a cottage with one-, two-, and three-bedroom suites available. All the suites have a living room, dining area, full kitchen, and private deck. Guests can use the complimentary bikes on-site to explore the town or stay on the property to use the fitness center, tennis courts, and game room.

The Bay Shore Inn has a private beach on the property for guests to use and free use of kayaks. There are indoor and outdoor pools and extras that families will like, including a children's playground and a campfire pit. For days when you need extra pampering, you can get a massage from the on-site massage therapist.

Address: 4205 Bay Shore Drive, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Bay Shore Inn

2. Holiday Music Motel

Photo Source: Holiday Music Motel

For a truly memorable place to stay in Sturgeon Bay, the Holiday Music Motel is one of the most unique lodging options. It is the first motel in Sturgeon Bay built in 1952, and its claim to fame is the fact that it is a notable songwriting retreat with a radio station that only plays music that was written on the premises. The independently owned motel is close to the waterfront and the shops and restaurants in Sturgeon Bay. Not surprisingly, there is lots of live music and concerts in addition to the tunes played that were written and recorded at the motel.

All the guest rooms have a retro feel with décor created by local artists. Rooms have mini refrigerators, free Wi-Fi and microwaves that are available in the King Deluxe rooms. Guests get complimentary breakfast in the diner that allows guest access 24/7 to the coffee pot and microwave. In addition to the weekly live music, guests can spend social time around the on-site fire pit or relaxing in the outdoor seating in the public area.

Address: 30 N. 1stAve, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Holiday Music Motel

3. Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort

Photo Source: Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort

If scenic views are a top priority then the Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort is a nice option. It is an all-suite resort that has scenic views from the balcony of every room. The Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort is close to all the shopping and restaurants in downtown Sturgeon Bay and it can be a home base for day trips up the peninsula to other Door County villages.

There are 38 suites designed with separate living, sleeping, and dining areas. All the suites have full kitchens, whirlpool tubs, gas fireplaces, and comfortable covered balconies. The property has indoor and outdoor pools, picnic areas on the shoreline, free Wi-Fi, and free paddleboat rentals for guests.

Address: 4303 Bay Shore Drive, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Westwood Shores Waterfront Resort

4. AmericInn by Wyndham Sturgeon Bay

Photo Source: AmericInn by Wyndham Sturgeon Bay

The AmericInn by Wyndham is a chain hotel located off Highway 42, so it is convenient to get to Sturgeon Bay or access the other villages, parks, and waterways along the Door County peninsula. The hotel is located close to Potawtomi State Park; the Sturgeon Bay waterfront; and the working farm at Schopf's Hilltop Dairy, which is a must-visit in the town.

AmericInn guest rooms have mini refrigerators, a microwave, coffee maker, and work space. You can upgrade rooms to get a fireplace and/or whirlpool tub. Guests get free Wi-Fi during their stay and a complimentary hot breakfast. There is a heated indoor pool, whirlpool, sauna, and fitness center.

Address: 622 S. Ashland Avenue, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: AmericInn by Wyndham Sturgeon Bay

5. Best Western Maritime Inn

Photo Source: Best Western Maritime Inn

The Best Western Maritime Inn is located in the heart of Sturgeon Bay, so guests are close to the water, shopping, orchards, and the Door County Maritime Museum. The hotel is pet-friendly with a number of nearby parks for easy walking access. Guests are within walking distance of local restaurants and a short drive to local golf courses and recreation.

Guest rooms have a refrigerator, microwave, coffee makers, and data ports for charging devices. Room upgrades are available for deluxe whirlpool suites or two-bedroom suites. Guests receive free Wi-Fi and a complimentary full breakfast buffet. The hotel has a heated indoor pool and hot tub for guests to use. There is a lobby fireplace and communal game room on-site.

Address: 1001 N. 14thAve., Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Best Western Maritime Inn

6. The Lodge at Leathem Smith

Photo Source: The Lodge at Leathem Smith

A luxury lodging option in Sturgeon Bay is the Lodge at Leathem Smith. It has many extras that chain hotels do not offer, like live music at the lodge on some evenings, a fish fry for guests, and a marina for boaters. The lodge is located right on the shores of Lake Michigan, so there's never a bad view and always the best seat for evening sunsets.

The guest rooms and suites at the lodge have kitchenettes, private patios, and whirlpool baths. Some rooms include an additional dining area and gas fireplace. There are lodge rooms in the main building and suite options available with a range of space up to 740 square feet. Guests receive complimentary breakfast and free Wi-Fi, and the hotel has an on-site pool.

Address: 1640 Memorial Drive, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: The Lodge at Leathem Smith

7. Beach Harbor Resort

Photo Source: Beach Harbor Resort

The waterfront access from the Beach Harbor Resort is one of its most popular features. It is a family-owned resort that provides special attention to guests and their requests for things like a romantic getaway. The resort is not far from Sturgeon Bay attractions and local orchards and parks but there is so much to do on-site that you can spend some time on the property to enjoy the location.

The resort has motel rooms and cottages that come with a microwave, refrigerator, and free Wi-Fi. Cottages are ideal for couples and families because they have a lot of space for sleeping, and living areas and decks on the lake. Guests receive a complimentary continental breakfast and have full access to the resort's sandy beach and waterfront fire pit. You can book fishing and boating charters, boats, and Jet Skis through the resort. Guests can use the kayaks and paddle boards free of charge at the resort's beach.

Address: 3662 N. Duluth Ave., Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Beach Harbor Resort

8. Cherry Hills Golf & Lodge

Photo Source: Cherry Hills Golf & Lodge

The Cherry Hills Golf and Lodge is perfect for anyone heading to Door County to hit the links. It is located on an 18-hole public golf course that is described as being challenging enough for experienced players yet still inviting for novice golfers. There is a practice facility and golf shop on-site.

Needless to say, the guest rooms have stunning panoramic views of the course and the beautiful Door County landscape. Guest rooms have walk-out balconies, free Wi-Fi, and sitting areas. There is casual dining on the property, and the lodge is close to other restaurants in Sturgeon Bay.

Address: 5905 Dunn Road, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Cherry Hills Golf & Lodge

9. Snug Harbor Inn

Photo Source: Snug Harbor Inn

The Snug Harbor Inn is a private retreat that has the comforts of home while guests are on vacation. It is especially nice for couples who are looking for a romantic getaway. It is located close to the Door County Maritime Museum and the Sturgeon Bay Ship Canal North Pierhead Light, so there is plenty to do nearby. The inn is pet-friendly and provides guests access to fire pits, grills, and boat rentals.

The Snug Harbor Inn has a variety of guests rooms, suites, and cottages. Studio rooms have two beds, full kitchens, sitting and dining areas, and two entrances. Smaller suites have one bed, a refrigerator and microwave, and a waterfront patio. Luxury suites have four-poster beds, a fireplace, and a whirlpool tub—great for couples. They also have an upstairs with a spiral staircase, balcony, and an additional bed. Cottages are suitable for families with several to choose from and come with full home amenities.

Address: 1627 Memorial Drive, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Snug Harbor Inn

10. Super 8 by Wyndham

Photo Source: Super 8 by Wyndham

A nice chain hotel in Sturgeon Bay is the Super 8 by Wyndham, located right between Green Bay and Lake Michigan, so you can get to either side of the Door County peninsula quickly. The hotel location is also close to Sunset Park and downtown Sturgeon Bay.

While it is off the main thoroughfare through Sturgeon Bay, you are close to the Door County Maritime Museum and several local café's that are known for their home-cooked meals. The Super 8 rooms have basic amenities and include a refrigerator, microwave, and coffee maker. Guests get free Wi-Fi, complimentary breakfast, and access to the indoor pool and hot tub.

Address: 409 Green Bay Road, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Super 8 by Wyndham

11. Quality Inn & Suites

Photo Source: Quality Inn & Suites

The Quality Inn & Suites hotel in Sturgeon Bay has basic amenities and comfortable lodging. The hotel is close to downtown Sturgeon Bay and near some of the best parks in the region, including Peninsula State Park, Potawatomi State Park, and Whitefish Dunes State Park. Being close to parks and trails is especially nice for guests who are traveling with pets and staying at this pet-friendly hotel.

The rooms at the Quality Inn and Suites have microwaves, refrigerators, and coffee makers. Guests get free Wi-Fi, complimentary breakfast, and on-site laundry facilities. There is a pool on the property and a nearby public golf course. The hotel is close to several restaurants, so you do not have to go far to find casual dining.

Address: 923 Green Bay Road, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Quality Inn & Suites

12. The Foxglove Inn

Photo Source: The Foxglove Inn

A nice getaway with luxury accommodations is The Foxglove Inn, with elegant décor and impeccably detailed guest rooms inside a large home. The inn is a historical home that was built by shipbuilders in 1877 for a Sturgeon Bay entrepreneur. The interior has been renovated with luxury suites, but the exterior maintains its original appeal.

Each suite is unique, with different décor and amenities. The rooms are designed for a quiet retreat, so they are nice for a romantic getaway or for guests who are celebrating a special occasion. Some rooms have fireplaces, whirlpool tubs, sitting areas, porches, chandeliers, and 12-foot ceilings. All suites have a mini refrigerator, television, and free Wi-Fi. The complimentary breakfast is delivered to your room each morning. Upgrades are available to make the visit extra special like spa treatments, flowers, and in-room massages.

Address: 344 N. 3rdAve., Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: The Foxglove Inn

13. Garden Gate Bed and Breakfast

Photo Source: Garden Gate Bed and Breakfast

The signature experience at the Garden Gate Bed and Breakfast is the elaborate breakfast. It is served each morning in the dining room with music and a quiet ambience to start your day. Guests can also indulge in an evening dessert before calling it a day. The Victorian home is appropriately located in the historic area near downtown Sturgeon Bay.

Each guest room is uniquely decorated with luxury bedding and fireplaces. Some rooms have a whirlpool or a balcony where you can enjoy your morning coffee as the town comes alive. Stroll the gardens on the grounds or make your way into the town to experience one of the Sturgeon Bay farmers markets, held on Saturday from June through October. Breakfast and evening desserts are included in the stay.

Address: 434 N. 3rdAve., Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Garden Gate Bed and Breakfast

14. Scofield House Bed and Breakfast

Photo Source: Scofield House Bed and Breakfast

The romantic flare of the Scofield House Bed and Breakfast is one of the reasons so many guests book it for special occasions. The Victorian home was built in 1902 for a prominent Sturgeon Bay businessman who went on to be the mayor. The Scofield House now has six rooms, each with individual décor and architecture, as well as stained glass, crystal, and hardwood floors throughout the main areas.

The guest rooms feature antique furniture to fit with the period of the home but have modern amenities for comfort and convenience, like free Wi-Fi, refrigerators, fireplaces, complimentary water and soft drinks, televisions, and private balconies. A complimentary breakfast is included in the stay, which includes homemade delicacies from the region. You can also get a breakfast to go if you are heading out early.

Address: 908 Michigan Street, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Scofield House Bed and Breakfast

15. Chanticleer Guest House

Photo Source: Chanticleer Guest House

One of the most elegant lodging properties in Sturgeon Bay is the Chanticleer Guest House, located on 80 acres of private land. The property has eight suites and four nearby cabins. It is located on a working sheep farm, so guests get to see authentic farm life in action during their stay. All the guest suites have fireplaces, double whirlpool tubs, free Wi-Fi, and a warm ambience. Guests receive complimentary breakfast that is delivered to their door each morning.

Address: 4072 Cherry Road, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Chanticleer Guest House

More Related Articles on PlanetWare.com

Exploring Door County: If you are looking for activities to experience during your trip to Door County there are 19 villages and Wisconsin small towns to visit along the 70 miles of the peninsula. There are five state parks that have hundreds of miles of hiking and biking trails and some of the best kayaking in Door County. Since the peninsula has more than 300 miles of shoreline, you will be able to enjoy some of the top beaches in Wisconsin without having to go far. Door County is a family-friendly vacation spot but also ideal for romantic getaways because of the charm and seclusion that the region offers.

Discover destinations, find outdoor adventures, follow the journeys of our travel writers around the world, and be inspired.

More on Wisconsin