15 Best Hotels in Fish Creek, WI

Written by Anietra Hamper
Jul 30, 2019

All the hotels and lodging options in the small village of Fish Creek in Wisconsin's Door County peninsula beckon the kind of vacation getaway that has been a tradition here since the early 1900s. You will not find large chain hotels, instead you will experience quaint, independently owned places to stay. Since the area was one of the first vacation spots in Door County, especially for summer tourists, many of the hotels offer suites that can accommodate families and visitors who are planning to stay more than a few days.

The village is small, so almost any hotel is in close proximity to the boutique shops, historic dining options, and recreational areas like Peninsula State Park, Nicolet Bay Beach, and Sunset Beach Park. Since the peak summer season in Door County is short, many hotels in Fish Creek may require a three-night minimum stay. While many hotels are open year-round, some are only open seasonally.

1. Homestead Suites

Photo Source: Homestead Suites

Homestead Suites is one of the most popular independently owned resort hotels in Fish Creek. The hotel has luxury rooms and suites in the main lodge but it also offers condominiums and home rentals. The hotel is within walking distance to all of the Fish Creek attractions, parks, and public beaches.

The suites have options including a gas fireplace, whirlpool tub, walk-in rain showers, refrigerator, and microwave. Homestead Suites has indoor and outdoor pools, a whirlpool and sauna, and a fitness center. Guests receive free continental breakfast.

If you have a family or are traveling with a group, the five-bedroom Homestead Park House is a rental home that sleeps up to 14 people and has a full kitchen and living area. There is also a fireplace and outdoor patio. The townhouse condos and other guesthouses accommodate four or six guests.

Address: 4006 Main Street, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Homestead Suites

2. Settlement Courtyard Inn & Lavender Spa

Photo Source: Settlement Courtyard Inn & Lavender Spa

The Settlement Courtyard Inn and Lavender Spa is a quiet country inn that is an elegant and luxury getaway in Fish Creek. The inn sits on a 200-acre estate, with four miles of hiking trails, views of the Green Bay waterfront, and a deck looking out over the limestone bluff. It is also close to the Fish Creek boutique shops and galleries and Peninsula State Park.

The suites all have kitchenettes, whirlpool tubs, and fireplaces. Guests receive complimentary breakfast, free Wi-Fi and access to the outdoor pool. There are activities on-site like horseshoes, grills to use, gardens to stroll, volleyball, and even a sandbox for kids. The on-site Lavender spa has a full menu of services that include massages, facials, aromatherapy, and couples' romantic packages.

Address: 9126 State Hwy. 42, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Settlement Courtyard Inn & Lavender Spa

3. Parkwood Lodge

Photo Source: Parkwood Lodge

The Parkwood Lodge is located on 10 acres and close to Peninsula State Park on the northern end of Fish Creek. The location is close to golf courses, theaters, biking and hiking trails, boating, lighthouses, and locations for you to try a traditional Door County Wisconsin fish boil.

There are several room options available at Parkwood Lodge, from simple rooms ideal for a solo traveler to family suites that sleep up to seven people. Room options include kitchenettes, fire places, and family bunk-bed rooms. The property has an indoor pool and whirlpool; free Wi-Fi; and guest access to grills, picnic areas, tennis courts, and a fire pit. Parkwood Lodge is open seasonally from May through October.

Address: 3775 State Hwy., 42, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Parkwood Lodge

4. Cedar Court Inn

Photo Source: Cedar Court Inn

The Cedar Court Inn has a wide range of lodging options, from simple motel rooms to three-bedroom cottages. It is close to the water, so taking in a boat tour, boat rental, or catching a spectacular Door County sunset on the bay is easy. The Cedar Court Inn is centrally located in Fish Creek, so you are only a few minutes from Main Street. Guests can access the property's outdoor pool, gardens, private courtyard, and nearby trails.

Motel rooms have refrigerators and coffee makers and access to the outdoor pool. The adults-only specialty motel rooms have a refrigerator, gas fireplace, and whirlpool tub. The Cedar Court suites can sleep up to four people and have a spacious floor plan with a kitchen, dining space, private deck, living room, gas fireplace, and whirlpool tub.

For larger groups, the four townhouse cottages on the property offer the most private accommodations. They have full kitchens, a laundry, and two-and three-bedroom options.

Address: 9429 Cedar Street, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Cedar Court Inn

5. AppleCreek Resort

Photo Source: AppleCreek Resort

The AppleCreek Resort Hotel and Suites is in a nice location just off the main corridor of the Fish Creek village but it is still within walking distance of Main Street and nearby attractions like Peninsula State Park and Nicolet Bay Beach. The resort has an indoor pool, hot tub, and sun deck.

Guest rooms have refrigerators, free Wi-Fi, and televisions. Suites are available that come with fireplaces, whirlpool tubs, microwaves, and an upper or lower balcony. A guest house is available that can accommodate two couples or a family. It has two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a fireplace, a full kitchen, and a whirlpool.

AppleCreek Resort also operates vacation home cottages that are located on another property. The rentals are pet-friendly homes with full yards and amenities for people taking longer vacations.

Address: 3941 WI Hwy 42, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: AppleCreek Resort

6. The Hilltop Inn

Photo Source: The Hilltop Inn

The townhome accommodations at The Hilltop Inn are a nice lodging option for people who are traveling with families. The location is across the street from the Top of the Hill Shops, local dining, and next door to the Peninsula School of Art, where you can take a class during your stay. For outdoor activities, The Hilltop Inn is close to the Peninsula State Park, local golf courses, and hiking trails.

The two-bedroom condos are fully furnished and have full kitchens, whirlpool tubs, a living room area, and fireplace. The condos have free Wi-Fi and private decks and chairs to enjoy your own space. Guests have access to the Hilltop Inn's outdoor pool, hot tub, and grilling area. It is open year-round for rentals.

Address: 3908 County Road F, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: The Hilltop Inn

7. Thorp House Inn & Cottages

Photo Source: Thorp House Inn & Cottages

The Thorp House Inn and Cottages offers specialty bed and breakfast lodging, which is nice if you are celebrating a special occasion or getaway. The Inn is one of the original lodging locations in Fish Creek, hosting vacationers for more than a century. It is located within a short walk to the Peninsula State Park and Sunset Beach Park and close to local dining establishments.

The Inn has five elegant rooms, each with luxury amenities and sitting space. Whirlpool spa tubs and fireplaces are available in a few of them. The inn's rooms are adults-only and include a homemade breakfast in the main dining room.

In addition to the inn, six private cottages have either one or two beds, and each is decorated with antiques and provides more space for families. Some have whirlpools and fireplaces. The Thorp House Inn and Cottages is open year-round.

Address: 4135 Bluff Lane, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Thorp House Inn & Cottages

8. White Gull Inn

Photo Source: White Gull Inn

The White Gull Inn has high-end luxury rooms and also features one of the most popular Door County fish boils in Fish Creek. The bed and breakfast is a renovated 1896 property in the center of Fish Creek, so all of the village boutiques and cafés are just steps from the inn.

The bed and breakfast has 17 uniquely decorated suites and cottages. Most have the added comforts of a fireplace and double whirlpools. Guests receive a complimentary full breakfast and morning coffee delivered to their rooms. The White Gull Inn has a full public restaurant on-site that serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner and the famous fish boils four nights a week featuring locally caught whitefish.

Address: 4225 Main Street, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: White Gull Inn

9. Evergreen Hill Condominiums

Photo Source: Evergreen Hill Condominiums

One of the closest properties to the entrance of Peninsula State Park is Evergreen Hill Condominiums. They are two-bedroom townhome condominiums that have full amenities and are located close to many of the outdoor activities that Fish Creek has to offer. In addition to the state park and the hiking and water activities, the condos are less than a 10-minute walk from Nicolet Bay Beach and Sunset Beach Park.

The condominium lodging offers a private and spacious alternative to a hotel room. The two-level condos have two beds, a two-person whirlpool tub, a full kitchen, and a lounge area with a fireplace. There is also dining space and a poolside deck on the main level. Guests can access the outdoor pool on the property and get free Wi-Fi.

Address: 3932 Evergreen Road, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Evergreen Hill Condominiums

10. Whistling Swan Inn

Photo Source: Whistling Swan Inn

The Whistling Swan Inn is the oldest inn located in the Door County peninsula. The historic 1887 inn is part of the Welcker Historic District and listed on the National Historic Register, so even if you do not book a room here, it is worth a visit just to see. The bed and breakfast has an operating restaurant on-site, with gourmet meals made from locally sourced vegetables, fish, and meats.

Guest rooms and suites are elegantly decorated to reflect the century-old style of the inn. The rooms have porcelain-tiled bathrooms, sitting spaces, and televisions. Some rooms have additional features like a sofa or work desk. Guests have free Wi-Fi and complimentary breakfast.

Address: 4192 Main Street, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Whistling Swan Inn

11. Peninsula Park-View

Photo Source: Peninsula Park-View

The family-owned Peninsula Park-View lodging has rooms, suites, and cottages in Fish Creek that offer a sense of old-style relaxed vacationing but with modern luxury. The historic Peninsula Park-View has lots of extras for guests, like free bike rentals, picnic areas, fire pits, an outdoor swimming pool, and services to pack a picnic basket for you as you head out for the day.

The rooms have one to three beds with a microwave, refrigerator, luxury linens, and large windows. Some rooms have electric fireplaces and dressers or closets. A family room option has bunk beds.

The suites are ideal for a romantic getaway or special occasions. They have extra space and are carefully decorated with artwork and have a kitchenette, over-sized showers, a fireplace, and more windows to accentuate the natural Door County beauty. There are also four cottages available with multiple bedrooms, full kitchens, and additional amenities for larger groups and families.

Address: 3397 State Hwy., 42, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Peninsula Park-View

12. Fish Creek Beach House

Photo Source: Fish Creek Beach House

The Fish Creek Beach House has two- and three-bedroom apartments that are great for vacationers who are staying longer than a few days. It is located close to all of the downtown Fish Creek activities, businesses, and restaurants. The waterfront lodging has some of the best views in Fish Creek, with the beach just across the street.

The apartment accommodations vary and can sleep two to four, or four to six people. They have full kitchens, two bedrooms, two bathrooms, living rooms, wood-burning fire places, free Wi-Fi, laundry, and a grill. The units also have a walk-out deck or balcony. Some units are pet-friendly with prior approval upon booking.

Address: 4117 Main Street, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Fish Creek Beach House

13. The Eagle Harbor Inn

Photo Source: The Eagle Harbor Inn

Since Fish Creek is one of the most popular communities in Door County and can often have sold out lodging in the high season, another close option is The Eagle Harbor Inn, just four miles away in neighboring Ephraim. It is just down the road, a few miles from downtown Fish Creek.

The Eagle Harbor Inn is a family-owned bed and breakfast that sits on a private five-acre property. The rooms have kitchenettes, and some have whirlpool tubs. Breakfast is included with the stay. The property features an indoor pool, fitness room, and free Wi-Fi. The inn is located across the street from the waterfront of Eagle Harbor Bay.

Address: 9914 Water Street, Ephraim, Wisconsin

Accommodation: The Eagle Harbor Inn

Best Motels in Fish Creek

1. Julie's Park Café & Motel

Photo Source: Julie's Park Café & Motel

If you want to stay in the heart of Fish Creek and also near the entrance to Peninsula State Park then Julie's Park Café and Motel is a great home base. The motel is within walking distance of great hiking trails, Nicolet Bay Beach, and Sunset Beach Park. Tours and rentals for mopeds and bicycles are just outside your front door, so you do not have to drive to take advantage of outdoor activities. The motel is open year-round.

The rooms at Julie's Park Café and Motel have simple amenities that include a couch, refrigerator, and coffee maker. Rooms are available that have a whirlpool tub and fireplace. There is a roomy café suite available that has a full kitchen and a dining and living room area.

The motel is pet-friendly, with many parks nearby for walking. The family-owned motel has a café on the property serving homemade bakery items, sandwiches, and coffee.

Address: 4020 State Hwy. 42, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Julie's Park Café & Motel

2. Main Street Motel

Photo Source: Main Street Motel

The Main Street Motel sits in the center of Main Street in Fish Creek, keeping you close to all the charming shops, dining, and activities in the village. Since many sightseeing tours and boat tours, like Door County Adventure Rafting, leave from the Fish Creek Town Dock, you can easily walk to these from the motel.

The Main Street Motel rooms are each themed and uniquely decorated, with several room types and price points available. All rooms include a refrigerator, free Wi-Fi, and television. The cheapest rooms are the single Queen rooms, which are smaller. The double Queen and the King rooms have more space for couples and families. Note that the motel is only open seasonally from May through October and it does not have an elevator.

Address: 4209 Main Street, Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Accommodation: Main Street Motel

More Related Articles on PlanetWare.com

Door County: During your stay in Door County, it is worth checking out the many communities along the peninsula and taking the ferry across Death's Door to Washington Island, where you can visit Schoolhouse Beach, made entirely of rocks, and visit the Lavender Isle lavender farm.

Wisconsin Outdoor Adventures: The state of Wisconsin is an outdoor enthusiast's playground. Start in Door County at the Peninsula State Park and take advantage of the hiking and biking trails. The summer in Wisconsin means fishing, boating, kayaking, beaches, and strolling through the cherry orchards. Wintertime is full of activities, too. Wisconsin is a top winter destination with trails for snowmobiling, fat tire biking, skiing, and snowshoeing.

Discover destinations, find outdoor adventures, follow the journeys of our travel writers around the world, and be inspired.

More on Wisconsin